The Sift: AI-generated “news” sites
![]() |
Note: The Sift is off next week for the Thanksgiving holiday. We will return to your inbox on Nov. 30 with a special issue featuring Dan Evon, host of NLP’s “Two Truths and AI” video series. |
Top picks
Here are the latest news literacy topics and tips on how to integrate them into your classroom.
Artificial intelligence technology cannot replace on-the-ground news reporting.
1. AI-generated ‘news’ sites popping up
AI-generated websites masquerading as legitimate local news are becoming more sophisticated and harder to detect — and some are even using real journalists’ names.
- AI-generated “news”: Journalists from the nonprofit newsroom called Billy Penn at WHYY investigated several Philadelphia and New Jersey “news” sites and found AI-generated articles and plagiarized content. The sites published bylines using the names of real journalists and even included fake headshots and fabricated bios.
- Journalism values: AI is used in some standards-based newsrooms, but its use should still align with core journalism values like transparency and accountability, according to Alex Mahadevan of the Poynter Institute.
- Getting information: While more people are using AI to get information, many say they don’t want news made entirely by AI. A new survey about AI use in nine countries, including the U.S., found that 38% of respondents said they used AI to get information within the past week, but only 12% were very or somewhat comfortable with AI-generated news.
💬 Discuss:
- Would you trust a “news” site produced entirely by AI? Why or why not?
- Can AI ever fully replace human journalists? What parts of reporting do you think require a human? Why?
- What clues can you look for to tell whether a news site follows standards like accuracy, fairness and accountability?
➡️For Families: Are your students’ families interested in this topic? Share the latest issue of Scroll Smarter, NLP’s monthly newsletter for families. And if you have a classroom newsletter, here is a folder of ready-to-go family engagement graphics you can include.
⭐ NLP Resources:
- Infographic: “Is it legit? Five steps for vetting a news source”
- Google Slides: “AI-generated news or not?”
- “Dig Deeper: How is AI affecting journalism?”
🔗 Related:
- “Should AI companies pay for the journalism they use?” (DW)
- “What 33 journalists learned about leading AI adoption” (Poynter)
2. AI slop about Inuk war hero spreads
Viral history posts are sometimes riddled with errors, and AI makes them easy to fabricate. Before you share any interesting stories, take a few minutes to confirm they’re accurate.
- Misinformation online: In a public Facebook group about world history, a post shared over 1,000 times contained several fabrications about the military service of Lance Cpl. John Shiwak, an Indigenous World War I hero from what is now northeastern Canada.
- AI-generated content: The post also included an AI-generated image of Shiwak, who died in 1917, holding a historically inaccurate gun from World War II and wearing an epaulette, or shoulder piece, from the 1950s.
- Real story: Military historian Frank Gogos said verifying the facts takes only a few minutes, while circulating the post risks misrepresenting Shiwak’s real story of heroism.
💬 Discuss:
- How can AI-generated content distort our understanding of historical stories like Shiwak’s?
- How can you verify claims about historical figures?
💡 Idea: Use the “Reflect” slide in Week 11 of the Daily Do Now resource to further explore this topic.
⭐ NLP Resources:
- Video: “Tutorial: Reverse image search”
- Infographic: “6 things to know about AI”
🔗 Related:
- “Why history instruction is critical for combating online misinformation” (The Conversation)
- “Australian Holocaust survivors turned into AI clickbait” (AAP FactCheck)
3. High school journalists covering local news
In Nashville, a student-run newspaper offers writers from 24 area high schools the chance to publish their work citywide, Poynter reported.
- How it works: The Nashville SUNN (Students United News Network) pairs college journalists with high school writers for mentoring. It launched a year ago and recently came out with its fourth issue, which featured contributions from about 20 student writers.
- Paid work: Student writers are paid between $50 and $125 per article, and many pitch their own stories. College editors at Vanderbilt University then help the teens get their stories ready for publication, teaching them about journalism standards and structure while walking them through edits.
💬 Discuss:
- What skills can someone develop by reporting and writing news stories that might be useful even if they don’t become journalists?
- What stories could high school writers report that adults might miss or have a harder time covering? Why?
⭐ NLP Resource:
- Interactive lesson: “Practicing Quality Journalism”
🔗 Related:
- “Student journalists are reporting more local news for real audiences. Their professors are exhausted.” (Nieman Lab)
- “Is It Crazy to Go to Journalism School?” (Columbia Journalism Review)
These interactive slide decks help students think carefully and critically about viral claims in the digital age.
No, Niagara Falls wasn’t lit up in blue to celebrate U.S. midterm results
❌ NO: Canada did not light Niagara Falls blue to celebrate Democratic victories in the U.S. midterm elections.
✅ YES: The Niagara Parks “Falls Illumination” schedule shows the famous waterfall was lit teal on Nov. 3 for Alzheimer’s Awareness Month.
✅ YES: A spokesperson for Niagara Parks told the AFP that “partisan political displays are not permitted” at the waterfall.
✅ YES: AI-generated images depicting other famous international landmarks lit up in blue, such as the Eiffel Tower in France and the Colosseum in Rome, also circulated online after the midterms.
⭐ NewsLit takeaway:
Presenting a genuine photograph out of context is one of the most common tactics to spread misinformation online. While Niagara Falls was truly lit with teal lights in November, it was not related to the U.S. midterm elections. Check out these Google Slides for tips on spotting these false context claims.
➕ The biggest product sold by health and wellness influencers: information. Pew Research Center found that 45% of influencers’ promotional posts pushed informational resources like workout programs, nutrition guides or podcast episodes.
➕ Over the last decade news consumers have increasingly turned to short-form vertical videos on social media, but there’s a new format on the horizon: longer, high-quality horizontal videos to stream on TVs.
➕ How do journalists separate personal beliefs from their work, especially when reporting on faith and extremism? Five African journalists shared their experiences with the Reuters Institute, describing the importance of approaching stories with sensitivity while still maintaining their impartiality and independence.
➕ Press freedom is shrinking in Egypt. The country is losing one of its last independent news outlets, Mada Masr, after a court convicted its editor-in-chief of operating without a license and ordered the outlet to close.
➕ Pink slime is partisan content pretending to be local news. In Ohio, a network of more than 60 pink slime sites shared political content during the recent U.S. midterm election cycle, according to an analysis by the Tow Center for Digital Journalism.
How do you like this newsletter?
Thanks for reading!
Your weekly issue of The Sift is created by Susan Minichiello, Dan Evon, Peter Adams, Hannah Covington and Pamela Brunskill. It is edited by Lourdes Venard and Mary Kane.
You’ll find teachable moments from our previous issues in the archives. Send your suggestions and success stories to thesift@newslit.org.
Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe to receive this newsletter in your inbox every Monday.
Check out NLP's Checkology virtual classroom, where students learn how to navigate today’s information landscape by developing news literacy skills.






