The Sift: News deserts on the rise
In this issue
News deserts on the rise | RumorGuard slides
Daily Do Now slides
A week’s worth of do-nows, just for you.
➡️ To access News Literacy Project resources linked in today's newsletter, sign up for a FREE Checkology® account.
Top picks
Here are the latest news literacy topics and tips on how to integrate them into your classroom.
It’s getting harder for Americans to access local news as more publications shutter.
1. News deserts on the rise
Having trouble accessing local news? The latest research shows you’re not alone.
- Fewer outlets: Over the last year, 170 local newspapers closed or merged, according to a new report by Northwestern University’s Medill Local News Initiative. Illinois lost more newspapers (30) than any other state.
- More news deserts: There are nearly 47 million Americans living with limited or no access to local news. Twenty-six more counties became news deserts in the last year, bringing the total to 238, the largest one-year jump since the Medill team began researching and tracking local news outlets five years ago.
- Rural-urban divide: There were 75 local news startups, mostly digital, but that number is not enough to keep up with the pace of newspaper closures. The majority of these new outlets are also in urban or more affluent areas, with news deserts spreading more in rural areas.
- Content creators: Researchers also reviewed 1,500 content creators across social media platforms but found only about 7% are covering local issues, and even fewer are doing original reporting.
💡Idea: Share the “News Decline” slide in Week 7 in the Daily Do Now resource to review the Local News Initiative’s local news map with students.
💬 Discuss:
- How do local news outlets affect day-to-day life in small communities?
- What role do local news outlets play in monitoring local government actions?
- What kind of information do you get from local news outlets that might be unavailable in national outlets?
- If there are no local journalists in your county, what other sources could you turn to for credible local news?
⭐ NLP Resources:
- Podcast: “Why democracy falters without local news”
- Interactive lesson: “Democracy’s Watchdog”
🔗 Related:
- “Local TV’s chokehold makes newspapers look competitive” (Axios)
- “The Berkeley Daily Planet has written its last headline” (Berkeleyside)
- Opinion: “Illinois newspaper’s downturn pushes out prodigy” (The Seattle Times)
2. How does The Associated Press count votes?
More than 100 million ballots will be cast in the upcoming U.S. midterm elections. All major American TV news networks (and even ChatGPT) will turn to one key source for results: The Associated Press.
- Background: The AP is a news agency that has counted U.S. election votes and declared results since 1848.
- Counting votes: There are over 5,000 “reporting units,” or local areas like counties, parishes or towns where the AP will collect election results, according to David Scott, vice president of elections at AP. The logistics of Election Day are different in every state.
- Accuracy takes time: After election results are gathered, the AP verifies the information. Scott noted accuracy is paramount, and he recommends being patient on election night. “It takes time to get things right,” he said.
💬 Discuss:
- Thousands of election officials count votes. Why does the AP collect these results and declare winners too?
- Why does it take additional time to verify information like election results or other types of breaking news?
- The AP had a 99.9% accuracy rate in the 2024 general election. What makes the news agency a credible source for election results? Where else can people turn for reliable information about elections and voting?
⭐ NLP Resources:
- Video: “Where to find election information”
- Infographic: “Three types of election rumors to avoid”
🔗 Related:
3. Congressman tells student reporter not to film
In public settings, it’s common for journalists to record elected officials. But recently a congressman told a student reporter not to — and threatened to have her prosecuted.
- Public interview: After a candidate debate on Oct. 13, reporters gathered to interview Maryland Rep. Andy Harris. On camera, he told Cat Murphy, a student reporter from the University of Maryland, that she wasn’t allowed to record.
- Two-party consent: Harris cited Maryland’s two-party consent law, which requires both parties’ consent to being recorded. However, the two were surrounded by several other journalists recording the exchange, and experts say the law isn’t applicable in public spaces where there isn’t an expectation of privacy.
- Journalists’ rights: Journalists have a legal right to openly record in public. Murphy later told CNN that she was focused on doing her job and plans to continue her coverage of Harris.
💡Idea: Share the video of the exchange between Harris and Murphy, then discuss the following questions.
💬 Discuss:
- Harris told the reporters: “She needs my approval to record.” Murphy responds: “Sir, we’re in public.” Do you agree with her response and her decision to continue recording?
- How do legal protections for journalists help safeguard press freedom?
⭐ NLP Resource:
- Interactive lesson: “The First Amendment”
🔗 Related:
- Report: “The Future of the First Amendment: Young Adults 2026” (Knight Foundation)
- “College journalism is thriving at schools that don’t teach it” (Poynter)
These interactive slide decks help students think carefully and critically about viral claims in the digital age.
No, Bill Gates did not say water shortage would cause a billion deaths
❌ NO: Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates did not say that water shortages could cause a billion deaths by 2027.
✅ YES: This is a doctored video that uses an AI voice clone to make it appear as if Gates made the comments.
✅ YES: The original video featured Gates talking about AI and its impact on the economy during an October 2025 interview with CNBC.
⭐ NewsLit takeaway:
AI voice clones can create realistic-sounding audio from public figures, making it seem they made statements they never actually said. Check out these Google Slides for tips on spotting these deceptive clips.
False claim that marks by poll workers invalidate ballots spreads again
❌ NO: Election ballots are not automatically disqualified if they are marked by poll workers.
✅ YES: Verbatim copies of this false rumor have circulated during previous elections.
✅ YES: Election officials in various states have released statements debunking this claim.
⭐ NewsLit takeaway:
Online falsehoods frequently cast doubt on the integrity of U.S. elections, often resurfacing word for word every election year. Read this article for tips on spotting these zombie rumors.
➕ As press freedoms erode in many countries, there’s a gap in international news coverage. Enter creators like Nazanin Nour, an Iranian American who does “journalism-adjacent work,” building a network of sources in and out of Iran and sharing timely updates with more than half a million followers across platforms.
➕ A new Hungarian government is easing press restrictions. Espionage charges against an investigative journalist were dropped and a daily political newspaper that shuttered a decade ago just relaunched.
➕ Should an AI-powered tutor for elementary students be legal? How should chatbots respond when a teen asks how to hide self-harm? These critical questions are part of a quiz on AI regulation by the New York Times’ Editorial Board.
➕ Eight states are suing OpenAI, saying it harms children in pursuit of profit. The lawsuits also contend that ChatGPT pretends to be agreeable but preys on teens by giving dangerous medical advice and encouraging harmful behaviors.
➕ Nieman Lab found that ChatGPT can not only copy the New Yorker’s distinct cartoon style — black-and-white, clean lines and incisive captions — but it has also added the signatures of at least 15 real cartoonists to AI-generated cartoons.
➕ Listening to music on YouTube? You may see new labels for AI-generated music: Fully Gen AI or Partly Gen AI.
➕ Can AI distort your memories? Scientists found that AI-generated content can plant false memories that people believe are real.
How do you like this newsletter?
Thanks for reading!
Your weekly issue of The Sift is created by Susan Minichiello, Dan Evon, Peter Adams, Hannah Covington and Pamela Brunskill. It is edited by Lourdes Venard and Mary Kane.
You’ll find teachable moments from our previous issues in the archives. Send your suggestions and success stories to thesift@newslit.org.
Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe to receive this newsletter in your inbox every Monday.
Check out NLP's Checkology virtual classroom, where students learn how to navigate today’s information landscape by developing news literacy skills.





