GSAN: Confusion breeds conspiracy | Debate rumors | News on YouTube


Learn about news literacy this week
Confusion breeds conspiracy | Debate rumors | News on YouTube

NOTE: Get Smart About News will not be published next week due to Monday’s federal holiday (Oct. 12). We’ll return on Tuesday, Oct. 20.

Confusion breeds conspiracy

When President Donald Trump tweeted at 12:54 a.m. ET on Oct. 2 that he and first lady Melania Trump had been diagnosed with COVID-19, it touched off a flood of conspiracy theories online from people seeking to make sense of the news. Some on the left and others critical of the president speculated that he was faking the diagnosis to avoid participating in more presidential debates, to gain sympathy votes or to distract everyone from The New York Times’ Sept. 27 investigative report about his taxes. Others suggested his intent was to stage a quick recovery to “prove” that the disease isn’t serious or to make himself look strong and healthy. Some on the right also thought he might be faking it to lure liberals into making disgraceful comments online, while others suggested that the Democrats infected the president to gain political power.

Disciples of the QAnon conspiracy theories read something into Trump’s diagnosis that no one else did: A cover to facilitate a “storm” of arrests to purge Washington of Hillary Clinton and other high-profile political figures who, they believe, are secretly Satanist pedophiles. (This is the core tenet of the QAnon belief system.) Unsurprisingly, they found “evidence” of this plan. In the last sentence of his tweet announcing his condition, Trump wrote, “We will get through this TOGETHER.” QAnon enthusiasts, eagerly searching for their preferred meaning, decided it was a secret code: “To get her.”

Note: People are often tempted to engage in conspiratorial thinking as they seek to make sense of major events — too often in ways that confirm their existing ideas and beliefs. In this case, a lack of transparency and a variety of conflicting accounts from the White House and Trump’s doctors have exacerbated people’s natural inclinations to engage in this type of thinking.

Viral rumor rundown

NO: The video in this tweet does not show bikers praying in support of President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump after they were diagnosed with COVID-19. YES: It is an Aug. 29 video of a protest against violent crimes targeting farmers in South Africa.


NO: President Donald Trump did not have an oxygen tank and tubing concealed under his jacket as he boarded Marine One to be taken to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center on Friday. YES: Trump was given oxygen at the White House on Friday before leaving for Walter Reed.


NO: Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden did not wear a wire during the first presidential debate on Sept. 29. YES: That is a fold in Biden’s shirt (you can see this moment in context here). NO: Biden does not have a transmitter implanted in his skull to receive debate guidance. NO: Biden did not have an IV or a wire running up his sleeve during the debate either. YES: He was wearing a rosary that he wears in remembrance of his son Beau, who died of brain cancer in 2015.

Note: The actor James Woods tweeted (archived here before the video was made private) a re-recording of this Facebook video playing on a computer monitor to his 2.6 million followers.

Also note: Recording a video playing on a computer screen is an easy way to reshare a video on another platform, but it is also sometimes used to evade automated detection of videos that have been flagged as problematic in some way.



★ NewsLit Picks

Suzannah: “How the everyday chaos of reporting on the Trump White House played out for the world to see Saturday” (Sarah Ellison, The Washington Post).

White House reporters have their work cut out for them. This report details what it was like for a pool reporter (who shares reporting with other news organizations) to cover news of President Donald Trump’s condition on Saturday. The article highlights the difficulty in trying to fact-check information on the fly for a fast-moving, urgent news story. The report also explores the delicate handling of information from an unnamed source who requested to speak with journalists “off the record” and agreed that a quote could be used as “background.” (In this case, the source was later identified by other reporters.)

Note: Legitimate news outlets have strict rules governing the use of unnamed or “anonymous” sources and typically their identities must be known to the reporter(s) and at least one editor.



Hannah: “Many Americans Get News on YouTube, Where News Organizations and Independent Producers Thrive Side by Side” (Pew Research Center).

A revealing new study from the Pew Research Center drives home just how central YouTube has become in many Americans’ news diets. About a quarter of U.S. adults turn to the video-sharing platform for news, but only about half of the news channels on YouTube are associated with established news organizations. According to the study, independent channels — or those without a clear affiliation with an organization — post much of the remaining news content. These channels are often personality-driven and more likely to cover conspiracy theories or approach subjects with a negative tone.


Peter: “Exclusive: Russian operation masqueraded as right-wing news site to target U.S. voters – sources” (Jack Stubbs, Reuters).

This is an important story that got buried in the avalanche of news about the first presidential debate and President Trump’s COVID-19 diagnosis. It’s about an FBI probe into a phony right-wing “news” website — called the Newsroom for American and European Based Citizens (NAEBC) — run by the Internet Research Agency (IRA), the Russian propaganda and troll factory that interfered in the 2016 presidential election. The site mainly focuses on U.S. politics (especially divisive issues) and paid unwitting Americans to write for it.

Note: This Reuters report is based on two unnamed sources familiar with the FBI investigation.

Also note: A little more than a month ago, the FBI told Facebook about another Russian IRA imposter “news” site called Peace Data that targeted progressives and paid unwitting American writers. The site is no longer active.

Key term: Attempts to mask state-sponsored propaganda stories by getting other individuals and organizations to write and publish them is a form of “information laundering.”


Thanks for reading!

Your weekly issue of Get Smart About News is created by Peter Adams (@PeterD_Adams), Suzannah Gonzales and Hannah Covington (@HannahCov) of the News Literacy Project. It is edited by NLP’s Mary Kane (@marykkane).

Sign up to receive NLP Connections (news about our work) or switch your subscription to the educator version of Get Smart About News called The Sift here.


Check out NLP's Checkology virtual classroom, where students learn how to navigate today’s information landscape by developing news literacy skills.