GSAN: Ukraine media bias? | False music video rumor | David Beckham’s insta takeover


Learn news literacy this week
Ukraine coverage bias? | False music video rumor | David Beckham's Insta takeover


Top picks

Discussion about mis- and disinformation online has spiked over the last two years, reflecting a heightened public awareness of the challenges presented by widespread falsehoods. According to data from the social media analysis firm Zignal Labs, mentions of “misinformation” and “disinformation” on Twitter increased 221% in 2020 compared with 2019 — largely coinciding with the rise of public conversations about COVID-19 and vaccines. Other major events, including the 2020 election and the Russian invasion of Ukraine, have sustained the public’s focus on the topic.
Mounting criticism of Western news coverage of the war in Ukraine raises important questions about the influence of bias in news decisions during major developing stories. Some have criticized certain reporting on Ukraine as racist and called attention to story framing and word choices that portray “the invasion as the sort of thing that happens in poor countries, but not in Europe.” Even just the sheer amount of coverage, critics say, reveals a double standard in how Western media has covered this war compared to conflicts in other parts of the world.
A year after the deadly Atlanta-area spa shootings, Asian American and Pacific Islander journalists are reflecting on coverage of the shootings and shining a light on continued anti-Asian violence across the country. Some have pointed out that coverage of the shooting deaths — which included six victims of Asian descent — underscores the importance of having newsrooms “with not only racial diversity,” but with “a variety of life experiences.”

Viral rumor rundown

Video of man smoking a cigarette in body bag is not from Ukraine

A tweet that says “Look at the fake body count in Ukraine. One of the bodies is still having his last cigarette lol.” The tweet contains a video of what appears to be a man in a body bag with an arm and his head out, smoking a cigarette. The News Literacy Project has added a label that says, 'FOOTAGE FROM MUSIC VIDEO SET.'

NO: This video is not from the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine. YES: It is footage from the set of a 2020 rap music video in Moscow. YES: The clip was posted to TikTok on March 28, 2021, by Vasya Ivanov, who is also credited as the production designer on the video.

NewsLit takeaway: A central Russian disinformation narrative during the war in Ukraine has been the baseless claim that Ukraine is faking or staging attacks and casualties. This falsehood has also gained traction among online communities of conspiracy theorists. In an attempt to legitimize this absurd notion, Russian government sources have pointed to misinformation circulating among people who appear to support Ukraine, even going so far as to fabricate pro-Ukraine “fakes” so that they can be “debunked” by sources echoing Russian government talking points. Prior to being shared widely in the false context of Ukraine, this clip circulated online in April 2021 to push the ridiculous claim that COVID-19 deaths were being faked. A different clip from the same music video set circulated online in September 2020 to falsely claim the body bags contained people who had died from COVID-19.


Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene didn’t refuse to applaud for Ukrainian President Zelenskyy

A tweet from that says “As Zelenskyy is greeted by the US Congress to a standing ovation, Marjorie Taylor Greene refuses to applaud and instead appears to grab her cell phone.” The News Literacy Project has added a label that says, 'FALSE.'

NO: Republican Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene didn’t refuse to applaud for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy when he spoke to Congress via videoconference on March 16. YES: Greene clapped at four different points during Zelenskyy’s appearance, as documented in this Twitter thread (archived here) by CNN’s Daniel Dale.

NewsLit takeaway: Controversial figures are frequent targets of misleading and false claims that resonate strongly among critics and partisan groups. The more polarizing the person at the center of the rumor is, the more inclined people who oppose them may be to uncritically accept and spread damaging falsehoods. When a misleading visual — especially a video, which may seem conclusive — is involved, it can touch off a wave of viral outrage. Remember: Our rational thinking is easily bypassed when we’re highly emotional. It’s always best to pause before you share or amplify information, and this is especially true when the content provokes a strong emotional response.


No, Congress didn’t vote to give itself a 21% pay raise

A tweet that says “While you are paying record prices at the grocery store and gas pump, our politicians in Congress voted for a 21% pay raise for themselves.” The News Literacy Project has added a label that says, 'MISLEADING.'

NO: Congress did not vote to give itself a 21% raise. YES: The spending bill signed by President Joe Biden on March 15 included a 21% increase to the Members’ Representational Allowance (MRA), which funds the legislative office budgets — but not the salaries — of members of Congress. YES: As The Associated Press reported, “Annual salaries for members of the House and Senate will remain the same this year, as they have since 2009.”

NewsLit takeaway: Complex pieces of legislation contain details that can easily be misrepresented and used to stir outrage by tapping into widespread concerns about government waste and corruption. In this case, a highly misleading headline published by the far-right website FrontPage Magazine sparked angry reactions and viral sharing across social media and was picked up by other conservative publications.

Soccer star David Beckham, a UNICEF Goodwill Ambassador, gave control of his Instagram account, which has more than 71 million followers, to a Ukrainian doctor who runs a perinatal center in Kharkiv to raise awareness about the humanitarian impact of the war and the challenges faced by patients and medical providers there.
How did the baseless “biolab” conspiracy theory — which falsely claims that the United States is secretly developing biological weapons in Ukraine — become a fixation of far-right conspiracy communities all over the world? Ben Collins of NBC News explains in this March 18 episode of On The Media.
Don’t miss this Education Week opinion piece on how the war in Ukraine offers students an opportunity to explore the history of misinformation and the ways “people seek meaning during periods of wrenching global upheaval.”
A producer at Russia’s government-run television network, Channel One, held up a poster on live television on March 14 condemning the war in Ukraine and warning viewers not to believe the network’s lies and propaganda. Marina Ovsyannikova was immediately arrested, and some fear she could face up to 15 years in prison under the country’s new law criminalizing information that conflicts with the government’s official narratives about the invasion of Ukraine.
Authorities in Germany have asked the public not to share a viral video in which a woman recounts a fabricated, secondhand story about Ukrainians in Germany attacking a Russian boy.
Brazil’s Supreme Court banned the social media app Telegram — which is favored by Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro — as part of a nationwide crackdown on hate speech and misinformation.
As Russia becomes more disconnected from the global internet, fears of an emerging “splinternet” — where "we have a number of national or regional networks that don’t speak to one another" — are rising.

Thanks for reading!

Your weekly issue of Get Smart About News is created by Peter Adams (@PeterD_Adams), Hannah Covington (@HannahCov) and Pamela Brunskill (@PamelaBrunskill), and edited by Mary Kane (@marykkane).

Sign up to receive NLP Connections (news about our work) or switch your subscription to the educator version of Get Smart About News called The Sift® here.


Check out NLP's Checkology virtual classroom, where you can learn to better navigate today’s information landscape by developing news literacy skills.